‹ Who Decides? (unit home)
① Surface · Build the knowledge

Phase 1 — Build the knowledge

Before students can reason about what kind of government to build, they need the raw material: the words, the main ways societies organize power, and a look at how two real governments actually work. These three activities are fast and front-loaded — the goal is acquisition, not yet analysis.

🎯 By the end of Phase 1 students can use the key vocabulary, explain the difference between limited and unlimited government, name the main ways societies organize who rules, and describe how two real governments differ.
Vocabulary & feedback · d 0.62§113.18(c)(9), (c)(10), (c)(12)

1 · Word bank & vocabulary sort

Introduce and let students sort the unit vocabulary. Sort twice: first into “words about who holds power” vs. “words about limits & rights,” then by student-invented categories (feedback on their reasoning).

WordKid-friendly meaning
governmentthe system a society uses to make and enforce its rules
limited governmenta government whose power has real limits (like a written law it must obey)
unlimited governmenta government whose power has few or no limits — leaders can do nearly anything
democracya government in which the people hold power, usually by voting
monarchya government led by a king or queen, often for life
republica government in which people elect representatives to make decisions for them
rule of lawthe idea that everyone, even leaders, must follow the same laws
citizenan official member of a country, with rights and responsibilities
rights & responsibilitiesfreedoms people are owed, and the duties they owe in return
constitutiona society's highest written plan for how it will govern itself
stakeholderanyone affected by a decision or who has something at stake

📚 Sources: iCivics · Foundations of Government ↗ · Britannica · Government ↗

Jigsaw method · d 0.92§113.18(c)(9), (c)(10), (c)(11), (c)(12)

2 · Jigsaw reading — How societies govern

Split the class into four expert groups, each studying one topic below, then re-mix into home groups where every topic is represented. Each expert teaches their group. (Jigsaw is one of the highest-leverage surface moves precisely because students must teach.)

🧩 Use the ACE Powered Jigsaw Organizer — experts capture their notes on it before teaching their home group: open the organizer ↗. New to running a jigsaw? See the teacher guides in the facilitator guide.

Sources for each expert group (free, reputable; confirm access through your district — links open in a new tab):

A · Limited vs. unlimited government

Some governments have real limits on their power — a written law they must follow. Others have few or no limits, and leaders can do nearly anything. This is the biggest difference between governments.

📄 iCivics · Foundations of Government ↗
📄 Britannica · Government ↗

B · Ways to organize government (who rules & how)

Power can rest with one person (a monarchy), a few, or everyone (a democracy or republic). Each way answers the same question — who decides? — in a different way.

📄 Britannica · Democracy ↗
📄 CIA World Factbook · Government types ↗

C · Citizenship — rights & responsibilities

Being a citizen means different things in different societies. What rights citizens are owed, and what duties they owe in return, varies from country to country.

📄 Britannica · Citizenship ↗
📄 iCivics · Citizenship & Participation ↗

D · The rule of law & protecting rights

The rule of law means everyone — even the most powerful leader — must follow the same laws. A constitution and protected rights are how societies keep power from being abused.

📄 Britannica · Rule of law ↗
📄 United Nations · Universal Declaration of Human Rights ↗

Check for understanding: each home group writes one sentence answering “Name one difference between limited and unlimited government, and one way societies decide who rules.”

📚 Sources: iCivics · Foundations of Government ↗ · Britannica · Government ↗ · CIA World Factbook · Government types ↗

Direct instruction · d 0.56§113.18(c)(10), (c)(13), (c)(14)

3 · Compare two real governments

Using country-profile sources, students compare two real governments — for example one that spreads power widely and one that concentrates it. Project or hand out the “Government” fields of a country profile (government type, how leaders are chosen, and citizens' role). Then fill in the compare chart below.

QuestionCountry 1 (e.g., Switzerland)Country 2 (e.g., Saudi Arabia)
What kind of government? (its type)
Who holds power — one, a few, or everyone?
How are leaders chosen?
Limited or unlimited power?

Quick write: “The government of ______ is ______ (limited/unlimited). Power is held by ______. It is different from ______ because ______.”

📚 Sources: CIA World Factbook · Switzerland (Government fields) ↗ · CIA World Factbook · Saudi Arabia (Government fields) ↗ · CIA World Factbook · Government types ↗

Surface check before moving on: can every student use the words limited government, unlimited government, rule of law, and citizen correctly, and name one way societies decide who rules? If yes, go deep. If not, reteach — the problem in Phase 3 depends on it.

Aligned to (not reproduced from) 19 TAC Ch.113 §113.18; effect sizes from Visible Learning MetaX. This region and scenario are a teaching fiction based on real questions about how societies govern themselves.

Who Decides? · Problem-Solving Teaching · Self-contained, no logins, no data collected. · Privacy & compliance