Answer Key: Thermal Energy at School
How to use this key
Answers are grouped by section and question number. Many items are open-ended; accept any response that shows correct reasoning even if the wording differs. Notes flag where more than one answer is defensible and list common misconceptions to watch for. Estimated grading time: ~5–7 min per packet.
Start Notice & Wonder grade for effort · ~2 min
1 Metal vs. wood at the same temperature.
2 Two places at school that warm or cool.
Build Read the Science ~1 min
3 Which mode needs no particles + the example shown.
Apply Use the Data ~2 min
4 Observation (O) vs. Inference (I).
b) I — it explains a cause ("because the sun heated it by radiation").
c) O — a directly measured value (24 °C).
d) I — a reasoned conclusion about why it is cooler.
Observation = measured/seen directly; inference = a conclusion reasoned from evidence.
5 Sunlit (44 °C) vs. shaded (29 °C) concrete.
6 Classify each transfer.
6b — B (Convection). A fan moves warm air (a gas) around the room.
6c — C (Radiation). Sunlight (rays) warms the backpack.
7 Redesign reasoning (worked example).
- (i) Light-colored blinds: targets radiation. Blinds block/reflect incoming sunlight before it enters, so less radiant energy is absorbed inside. (Strongest choice — see Q8.)
- (ii) Fan: targets convection. Moving air mixes hot air away from students and speeds cooling; it does not stop energy from entering, so it helps less than blinds.
- (iii) Move desks to the far corner: uses the data (far corner air = 24 °C vs. near-window 27 °C). Reasonable, but it relocates students rather than reducing the heat entering — a weaker "fix."
Explain CER (Q8) ~1–2 min
8 Which choice most reduces heat transfer into a hot classroom?
Defensible alternates: A student may claim the fan is best if they argue convection removes built-up heat and cite Table 1's air readings; accept with sound reasoning, but the blinds argument is stronger because it addresses the source.
CER scoring rubric (3 points)
| Score | Claim | Evidence | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | Clear, correct choice stated. | Two accurate, relevant pieces from Table 1 and/or the diagram. | Correctly links evidence to a transfer mode and explains why it reduces heat. |
| 2 | Choice stated, mostly clear. | One solid piece, or two with a minor error. | Some correct linkage but incomplete or a small misconception. |
| 1 | Vague or partly correct choice. | Evidence weak, off-topic, or not from the sources. | Little or flawed reasoning; mode not correctly named. |
| 0 | No/incorrect claim. | No evidence. | No reasoning. |
Close ACE ~1 min
ACE Articulate / Connect / Extend.
Connect: the cited row/part must actually match the chosen mode (e.g., metal handrail 48 °C → conduction/radiation; heating vent → convection; sun through window → radiation).
Extend: any correct new, out-of-school example (e.g., conduction — a spoon in soup; convection — boiling water; radiation — a campfire warming your face). More than one answer is defensible.
Watch Common misconceptions
- "Cold flows in." Cold is not a substance. Thermal energy flows out of the warmer object; there is no "coldness" moving in.
- "Heat is a material/fluid inside things." Heat is energy transferring, not stuff stored; "thermal energy" is the particle motion energy.
- Metal is "colder" than wood. At the same temperature they are equal; metal only feels colder because it conducts energy from the hand faster (Q1).
- Confusing convection with radiation. If a fluid (air/water) carries the energy, it's convection; if rays cross a gap, it's radiation.
- Observation vs. inference (Q4). Students often mark a reasoned cause as an "observation." Any "because…" statement is usually an inference.
Teacher follow-up based on likely errors
If many students miss Q4b/Q4d, do a 5-minute sort of statements into "measured" vs. "concluded." If Q6 or Q3 reveal convection/radiation confusion, re-anchor with Figure 1 (rays vs. moving air). If CER (Q8) evidence is thin, model citing a specific Table 1 row aloud. The "cold flows in" misconception is the highest-value item to address next class.